Originally known as the Commissioner's Cup, the Sasser Cup was renamed in 2000 to honor the retiring George F. "Buddy" Sasser, who served as the Conference Commissioner from 1989 to 1996. Below are the annual champions of the Sasser Cup Trophy, as well as the winners of the Women's and Men's All-Sports Awards.

Sasser Cup Champions
2024-25 -- High Point
2023-24 -- High Point
2022-23 -- High Point
2021-22 -- High Point
2020-21 -- Campbell
2019-20 -- none - incomplete season due to COVID-19 pandemic
2018-19 -- Campbell
2017-18 -- Liberty
2016-17 -- Liberty
2015-16 -- Liberty
2014-15 -- Coastal Carolina
2013-14 -- Coastal Carolina
2012-13 -- Liberty
2011-12 -- Liberty
2010-11 -- Liberty
2009-10 -- Liberty
2008-09 -- Liberty
2007-08 -- Liberty
2006-07 -- Coastal Carolina
2005-06 -- Coastal Carolina
2004-05 -- Coastal Carolina
2003-04 -- Coastal Carolina
2002-03 -- Liberty
2001-02 -- Liberty
2000-01 -- Coastal Carolina
1999-00 -- Liberty
1998-99 -- Liberty
1997-98 -- Liberty
1996-97 -- UNC Greensboro
1995-96 -- UNC Greensboro
1994-95 -- UNC Greensboro
1993-94 -- Campbell
1992-93 -- Campbell
1991-92 -- Campbell
1990-91 -- Coastal Carolina
1989-90 -- Coastal Carolina
1988-89 -- Coastal Carolina
1987-88 -- Coastal Carolina
1986-87 -- Winthrop
1985-86 -- Winthrop

Women's All-Sports Award
2024-25 -- High Point
2023-24 -- High Point
2022-23 -- High Point
2021-22 -- High Point
2020-21 -- High Point
2019-20 -- none - incomplete season due to COVID-19 pandemic
2018-19 -- High Point
2017-18 -- High Point
2016-17 -- Liberty
2015-16 -- Liberty
2014-15 -- Liberty
2013-14 -- Coastal Carolina
2012-13 -- Liberty
2011-12 -- Liberty
2010-11 -- Liberty
2009-10 -- Liberty
2008-09 -- Coastal Carolina
2007-08 -- Liberty
2006-07 -- Coastal Carolina
2005-06 -- Coastal Carolina
2004-05 -- Coastal Carolina
2003-04 -- Coastal Carolina

Men's All-Sports Award
2024-25 -- High Point
2023-24 -- High Point
2022-23 -- Campbell
2021-22 -- Campbell
2020-21 -- Campbell
2019-20 -- none - incomplete season due to COVID-19 pandemic
2018-19 -- Campbell
2017-18 -- Campbell
2016-17 -- Liberty
2015-16 -- Liberty
2014-15 -- Coastal Carolina
2013-14 -- Coastal Carolina
2012-13 -- Coastal Carolina
2011-12 -- Liberty
2010-11 -- Coastal Carolina
2009-10 -- Coastal Carolina
2008-09 -- Liberty
2007-08 -- Liberty
2006-07 -- Winthrop
2005-06 -- Coastal Carolina
2004-05 -- Liberty
2003-04 -- Liberty